Bureaucracy kills the joy

One of my themes is how over-regulation makes life on the roads a misery when it could be a pleasure. Bureaucracy too can kill the joy. From Freedom for Drivers Foundation:

The FT on planning impediments to a major congestion-cutting project:

“Lower Thames Crossing has cost £1.2bn even before construction starts. The scheme to build a 14-mile road and tunnel to connect Kent and Essex has become a totem of our snarled-up planning system, in which ventures are tied up with years of delays and mountains of expensive compliance documents.

The planning document for the project — the first wholly-new Thames river crossing east of London for 60 years — runs to 359,070 pages, while it employs around 150 staff and an eight-strong management team.”

This is another example of UK management incompetence with overpaid consultants creaming off enormous fees and delaying projects …

FT article in full: https://www.ft.com/content/917d4b7f-318e-46fe-ba44-664551ebcf13

My comment: Ludicrous/depressing/wasteful indeed. What was that story I read a while ago about a project that was into 6 figures of paperwork, 8 figures of outlay on consultants, yet not even started, while Norway built a bridge over a wide inlet within a year of it being proposed … something like that. Do we suffer from a “can’t do” attitude? On the plus side, a stretch of the A303 at Sparkford has just been completed and it’s great.

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Peace on the roads?

The way to achieve peace on our roads is not through regulation or technology.

It’s through a change in the rules from priority to equality. Arrive first? Go first, whether you’re on foot or on wheels. In the absence of bridge or flyover, let all junctions, and streets for that matter, be all-way give-ways.

The driving test must be reformed in line with the sociable culture of equality.

No-one gets a driving licence without cycling proficiency and a rider’s licence. Exceptions for the disabled.

Make the driving test much harder, to include skid pan experience and virtual reality training to inculcate the danger of inappropriate speed.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Old post

Just came across an old blogging site I used to use. It doesn’t seem fully functional, which isn’t surprising as it’s 16 years since I wrote this post (dated 2.3.2009):

Depressing announcement from the Association of Chief Police Officers. They propose average speed cameras instead of traffic calming measures in built-up areas to deter “speeding”. You can understand the rationale, but isn’t it misguided to extend state control at the expense of personal responsibility?

Speeding is a fabricated crime, like jaywalking. It’s not speed that kills, but inappropriate speed, or speed in the wrong hands.

Don’t policymakers realise that people behave worse when herded and hounded, and better when free to act according to commonsense and context?

Is it time to start installing traffic lights at cashpoints, and speed cameras on pavements, or time to start treating road-users as grown-ups?

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Equality Streets

When the regulatory framework of traffic control is removed, as when traffic lights break down, we rediscover our humanity and make common cause. As soon as we are free from the coercive control that prevents infinite filtering opportunities and expressions of fellow feeling, the traffic and the milk of human kindness begin to flow.

To support the sociable interaction that blossoms when we’re free of regulation and free to use our own judgement, these elements are required:

New rules of the road and a new driving test, based on equality for all road-users.

Roads and streets re-designed to express equality.

On Equality Streets, all road-users are equal, but some – the vulnerable – are more equal than others.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

The power of platforms

The commotion over Allison Pearson’s non-hate crime investigation by Essex Police for a deleted tweet highlights the unequal power enjoyed by those with a public platform. In her critique of police time wasted on a thought crime instead of real crime echoes identical objections by drivers who fall prey to the extortion racket otherwise known as “speeding”. You are driving in perfect safety but are zapped by a hidden copper wielding a concealed radar gun. Don’t the Police have more important things to do? we cry, slapped with points and fines for the non-crime of contravening an arbitrary limit that has nothing to do with context. While Pearson gets five-star, expenses-paid legal representation – resulting in a Police retraction, case dismissal and a change in the law – Jill and Joe Bloggs suffer abuse at the hands of a system that ignores their silenced screams. Yes, even Courts forbid any challenge to statutory law. While the powerful overturn vexatious law, the masses must submit to it.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

Drop in the ocean

The AA calls for graduated driving licences for young drivers with a 6 month moratorium on carrying passengers their own age. It’s a gesture in the right direction but a drop in the ocean. We need wholesale reform of the rules of the road and the driving test. The system should be based on equality for all road-users, with the vulnerable more equal than others. Drivers should learn the dangers of speed and the beauty of tolerance. As a basis for road-user interaction, sociable self-control would avoid the “need” for vexatious regulation and prompt safe, empathic, environmentally-friendly driving.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Falling on deaf ears

Annual casualties on our roads are equivalent to more than one Grenfell a day. Yet while Grenfell gets blanket media coverage, 30,000 equally avoidable road casualties – given that my umpteenth pitch to the Press has just been ignored – are unnewsworthy. Hard not to conclude that the media accept the carnage on our roads with indifference. In Your Car No-one Can Hear You Scream! was an early title for a pitch to TV. Seems that no-one can hear me scream from this blog either.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Ministerial mess – corporate manslaughter

Updated in July 2024, the DfT’s accredited “accident” statistics reveal that 29,643 human beings were killed or seriously injured in 2023. It’s an estimate of the number of personal injury road traffic casualties in Great Britain reported by the police using the STATS19 reporting system. The figures will change following the end-of-year validation process.

How is this number of disasters remotely acceptable? This is peacetime!

Practically all of these “accidents” are caused by the dangerous rules of the road, and the inadequate driving test, and completely avoidable.

It’s an absolute scandal that traffic authorities and MPs stand by and do NOTHING to treat the root cause instead of the symptoms!

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Never the carrot

This post, which reiterates stuff I’ve written before, but bears repetition, was prompted by news that transport minister, Louise Haigh, intends to fund more cycle lanes (which as a cyclist I dislike).

Most if not all coercive traffic interventions are pointless because they react to a system which is flawed – the system of priority, aka inequality.

The system imposes dangerous, conflicting rights-of-way. It segregates road-users instead of integrating them in a sociable mix.

Whether you walk, cycle, ride, or drive, you are a human road-user. Human beings grew up to respect the rights of others. The traffic system and the driving test teach us to ignore the rights of others.

You see it every day. People on foot at the side of the road, and side road drivers trying to get out, are ignored by drivers on the main road. Those drivers are obeying the anti-social rule of priority which they learned when they learned to drive.

But the rule is diabolical. It puts road-users at odds with each other. It makes us compete for gaps and green time. It subverts our social instinct to take it in turns. It’s not based on the common law principle of equal rights.

Why can’t we act on the road as we act in other walks of life? Why not make junctions all-way give-ways, and roads sociable spaces where we give way to others who were there first? When will the authorities think outside the box marked priority?

Given equality, we could cooperate in peace. It would be “After you” instead of “Get out of my way!” It would eliminate most “accidents”, which are mostly avoidable disasters contrived by the unequal rules of the road.

It would enable the removal of the paraphernalia of traffic control which blights the public realm, maximises congestion and emissions, and makes getting about a misery when it could be a pleasure.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

More coercive control in the public realm

Transport Secretary Louise Haigh has given her “absolute support” to more 20mph zones and LTNs (low traffic neighbourhoods).

Funding always seems to be available for coercive, divisive measures, yet re-education and road redesign – the consensual way to calm traffic and shift the balance of power in favour of the vulnerable – are not even tabled. It’s too often the expensive stick, rarely the cheap and cheerful carrot.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment